Fierce Food (Book Review) - [Reading]

Posted by Chubbypanda at 2/05/2007 02:05:00 AM

(Pictures for this review taken with my Canon Rebel XTi.)

Four months ago, Eddie Lin of Deep End Dining turned me on to the then newly published book, Fierce Food: The Intrepid Diner's Guide to the Unusual, Exotic, and Downright Bizarre by Christa Weil. After reading Eddie's review, I picked up a copy from my local bookstore and tore through the entire book in one sitting; not because it was that good, but because it was that short. Cover to cover, reading Fierce Food only took me an hour.



This trade paperback is far from an intellectual feast, weighing in at slightly over two hundred, double-spaced pages. Formatted as a guide for the adventurous diner, Fierce Food presents each featured food in a short essay that briefly covers history, cultural significance, and flavor.

Although the articles are informative, the problem with Fierce Food lies in its brevity. Few of the chapters are longer than two pages, giving Ms. Weil little room to cover a topic in anything approaching satisfactory detail. In addition, the list of foodstuffs seems almost random in its selection, with little focus or theme. Botfly larvae and human placenta are mixed in with foie gras and coconuts. The result is a book that feels shallow and incomplete.



My biggest issue with Fierce Food is that it seems like nothing more than a Dummies version of Jerry Hopkins' definitive Extreme Cuisine, the book Tony Bourdain himself refers to for all of his experimental eating. Some of the chapters in Fierce Food seem to be summations of chapters presented in Extreme Cuisine, often with disturbing similarities between articles.

On the other hand, Fierce Food isn't a bad book. Ms. Weil's prose is entertaining and occasionally engaging. She does a fair job providing the casual reader with a sampler of the delights this genre has to offer. If you're trying to open someone's mind to sampling exotic foods, Fierce Food may be the book you've been looking for. Just don't be surprised if it leaves them wanting something more.



Bottom Line: The book's structure and brevity make Fierce Food a decent addition to your bathroom or coffee table. It's an excellent conversation starter and would probably be a fun gift. The $14US price tag is also quite affordable. However, keep in mind that for $22US, you can pick up the highly detailed Extreme Cuisine, which you're sure to find much more satisfying.

Labels:

6 comments:

  1. Christine D. said... 2/05/2007 11:20:00 AM

    Wow, I totally agree with it being a bathroom book. The ~2 page descriptions for each food is perfect for those "sessions." :P If they were any longer, i'd get a hemorrhage from sitting there so long.

    I enjoyed it though, but wish that there were photographs. When I have more time, I'll get a more in depth book like Extreme Cuisine.  

  2. elmomonster said... 2/05/2007 11:01:00 PM

    I bought it too, ordered it when Eddie wrote the plug. I have to say that I enjoyed it. But then, I didn't realize there was an even better book in Extreme Cuisine. I do think that some chapters are kind of short on the tooth. She wrote down what she knew, but didn't actually try the items. I was hoping she would. Instead those chapters read like an encyclopedia entry, albeit a very interesting and well-written one.  

  3. Wandering Chopsticks said... 2/06/2007 08:45:00 AM

    Hmm. I think I'll just re-read my copy of A Cook's Tour.  

  4. Kathy said... 2/06/2007 02:04:00 PM

    i just got Mindless Eating and The Tummy Trilogy in the mail today! Is is food book reading season for everyone? :)  

  5. Deb said... 2/07/2007 06:21:00 PM

    Thanks for the review...if I saw/read about it, I to would probably have ran out and picked it up. think I can look this over at Borders without having to purchase!  

  6. Chubbypanda said... 2/08/2007 10:04:00 PM

    Christine,

    Extreme Cuisine is great. Some of the pictures are a little gruesome, but the information and writing are top notch. Best of all, Hopkins sites his sources, which Weil doesn't in Fierce Food.

    Elmo,

    You're spot on. I enjoyed the book as well, but in the end, I just wasn't satisfied with the ROI. The next time you're in a book store, find both Fierce Food and Extreme Cuisine. Look up an entry in both of them and compare the information. Then compare the prices. You'll see what I mean.

    WC,

    That's a great book. I need to pick up the series on DVD.

    Kathy,

    It's always food book reading season for me. =D

    Deb,

    Given how short it is, you could probably read Fierce Food in the book store coffee shop over a nice latte and only be out the price of the latte.  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)